MacLiam

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Not worse. In some minor regards, slightly better.

I have deleted the rest of my original comments. When I first posted, I didn't realize Paul had reported on this unit a couple of days earlier.

Four days after a cumulative update for 1809 took me to 17763.593, this morning the "you're not ready yet" notice was absent and 1903 was offered to me . This is for a first generation Surface Studio. I suppose the CU may have had something to do with it, but maybe not. Are other owners of Studios (or any other Surface device, for that matter) finding that after the latest CU they also can now update from 1809 to 1903?

When I posted a couple of times earlier today I saw for the first time an "Approve Comment" link in the upper right corner of my post after I clicked "submit." The post also had a never-seen-before red background. Is this for the use of moderators, or is it something I am supposed to click on to show I really want to post it? I did not approve my own comment, but the posts appeared in the forum thread anyway.

I also noted a red tint/approve combo on a "SPAMMERS" post I made several months ago.

If I misunderstand the "Dev" category, please move this to whatever section it belongs in.

I just took the $42 renewal offer until 9/2019 but don't understand why the actual cost was $54 and pennies. I don't mind paying the unexpected $12 since the total is still $10 less than the expected renewal would have been in October, but I'm just confused by the arithmetic. I think I saw a $0.38 credit mentioned as well, but I didn't do a screen cap before I went to the cart and paid.

I know you said in a recent FRD that pricing for the Premium subscription were being adjusted, but that the changes were in abeyance pending some fixes to the billing calculation. There may have been an explanation that I simply missed, but it feels to me that something may still be wrong.

Not angry or bothered about this, just don't understand.

Moments ago (about 2:15 PM Pacific Daylight Time) I got a toast notification that read, “Windows 10 Creators Update Has Shipped.” When I clicked on it, I was taken to Feedback Hub. Search reveals no post there with that title, and I am not sure what is noteworthy about such a notification anyway. The original CU has been available since early April, and it’s about a month too early for the Fall CU to go into release.

Anybody know what this is about? Are we just looking at another untimely button push from Microsoft?

In case you haven't yet found it on your own, the IFIXIT team have opened up a Surface Studio to show what lies inside the base and behind the screen.

https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Microsoft+Surface+Studio+Teardown/74448

FedEx dropped it off mid-day and I have been going through the update and transfer motions for the last five hours. First impressions — A+. This feels like the best computer I have ever had, which is what I previously said about the Surface Book much earlier this year.

I still haven’t had a chance to play seriously with the “creative” side of things, but some quick experiments with inking and screen annotation are fast, fluid and a pleasure to experience.

I toyed with the idea of recording the unboxing experience, but decided I didn’t have the patience. Somebody with experience in that kind of presentation will be along eventually to show what the package looks like and how everything is packed away. The packaging design and execution are extremely nice — nicer than they need to be, in fact, and I have to believe that a greater-than-tiny chunk of the purchase price goes to defray the cost of the boxes in which they send it to you. Even the outer shipping  carton is a cleverly folded huge piece of corrugated cardboard that with a couple of tape cuts falls open like a blooming lotus to let you easily remove the somewhat smaller and much more elegant container for the machine itself.

The Studio came with 14393.187 installed, and after initial setup I quickly updated and ended up with 14393.447 — that’s right, 447, not 448. I’m pretty sure I will go Fast Ring on this thing in the near future, but I will try to be patient and not rush immediately into an available version of the Creators Update. System updates installed today also included a WD driver and some security updates. Defender shipped with definitions from last May, but today’s update brought it current pretty quickly.

The screen is great — sharp, bright, and with roughly four times the area of a Surface Book screen. After a few months of working on an ultrawide extension monitor the proportions feel a little retro, but there is no denying that there is a lot of real estate to fill up with whatever kind of work anyone would want to do.

The mouse feels a little better engineered and more precise than other MS mice I have owned. The rectilinear keyboard is compact and a pleasure to use, but I splurged on the ergonomic keyboard as well and expect to be doing most of my keyboard work on that one as time goes by. There has proved to be a bit of a learning curve for the forefingers, what with the few oversize keys in the middle of the divided keyfield.

I haven’t tried out the Dial yet, but in the process of pairing it to the Studio I saw that it is called the “Wheel” in Settings section that lets you control it. I am shocked, shocked to learn that Microsoft appears to be not firmly in control of all aspects of its naming processes.

Moving into this machine is like moving into a new and larger apartment or house, so there is still a lot of organizing and preparation to get through before I really start using it for the stuff it is designed to do best. But that may start to happen over the weekend, and I will report back as the experience unfolds.

Any disappointments or unwelcome surprises? Maybe a small one. The swinging screen is completely gear driven, so you can’t put it at a custom height and custom angle at the same time; the higher you position it, the more vertical it gets; the lower you position it, the more it leans back. I suppose you could get a piece of one-by oak to go under the front or back of the base to adjust the screen position a little, but I’m not sure I’m upset enough by the limited flexibility of the geometry to want to bother.

Liking it a lot so far.

EDITED A DAY LATER TO ADD: Still moving in and getting organized, but taking moments to mess around with photograph editors, bit and vector drawing programs, musical performance and manipulation apps (I have a ROLI Seaboard Rise that I am trying to come to terms with) and so forth.

Just for grins i ran some overall benchmarks that might interest others. I compared the Studio (i7/980 GPU) to my older Surface book (slower i7 with the optional GPU); this is NOT the new Book with the augmented base.

Antutu v 6: Book, 254376; Studio 493588 (these are the results of second runs; first runs were each about 10% lower)

Passmark v 9: Book, 2336.8, 61st percentile; Studio, 4925.0, 94th percentile (these were also second runs with first runs also about 10% lower)

After further mouse use, I think I prefer an old Logitech M510 to the Surface Mouse. The Logitech mouse has an exaggerated Coke bottle shape that my fingers like on either hand; that mouse also has some additional buttons that are useful for paging forward and back in a browser. The Surface mouse isn’t bad; it just feels a little basic and blob-like in the hand. As a thing, though, its design minimalism makes it nice to look at as a tool in the Surface universe. A nice feature of the Surface Mouse and Dial is the magnetic battery cover on the bottom of the device. Simple to operate and you can’t bust off or damage any little plastic ears.

Speaking of magnets, I found out that the vertical edges of the screen have multiple magnets that let one stash the pen on either side in one of several different positions. That is a thoughtful design touch that should pay off in reduced irritation for a lot of graphics professionals.

There are other Thurrott devotees who ordered a Studio early on and should have it by now; please chime in with your thoughts about this machine.