Nostalgia Done Right ⭐

I previously defined a hipster as someone who is nostalgic for a past they did not experience. But whether it's real nostalgia--a wistful feeling experienced by those who remember a past that was in many ways preferable to the present--or the faux nostalgia we see in younger people buying vinyl records, cassette tapes, audio CDs, and even iPods, it's far too easy and too common to make a crucial mistake. Instead of remembering the past, we're remembering an idealized version of the past, one that conveniently leaves out the bad parts.

But there was good and bad in the past. For example, in the America of the 1950s, we weren't just pushing inequality on minorities and women, we were building out a national highway system that introduced an entirely new kind of freedom. And that meant we could listen to the radio, which in turn meant that we could listen to music anywhere a car could go.
This is who we were
I wasn't alive to witness that particular advance, but I did live through several eras in which an individual's ability to experience music when and where they wanted expanded greatly. And as a music fan, this was as liberating and exciting as the advances in personal technology that also happened in my lifetime.

Each advance was in some ways a step forward, but each also came with downsides.

For example, vinyl records had good sound quality, but the medium was easily scratched or otherwise damaged, including by something as innocuous as dust. Vinyl wasn't in any way portable because it relied on a rock-steady turntable in which several elements had to be perfectly aligned and configured. (That said, I knew someone who had a record player in their car. Yes, it was terrible.) And each side of a vinyl record could only hold so much content, so there was a lot of hand-holding during listening sessions.

8-track tapes brought portability to commercial albums but had even worse time-based limitations.

Cassette tapes were also portable but they gave us the ability to record music and other audio from the radio and other sources, but the sound quality was lackluster and the tape-based nature of the form factor made moving from track to track manual, time-consuming, and tedious.

Audio CDs brought music into the digital era, could contain more music on one side than an LP on two, solved the track selection problem, and were durable while allegedly offered "perfect" sound reproduction. But they could still be scratched, were problematic for portable use, and couldn't be recorded on as with cassettes, though those two latter issues were solved in time.

There were other advances before we moved from physical to digital media in the very late 1990s and 2000s, but the transitions noted above make the point: There were pros and cons at each step along the way, in each case, the pros outweighed the cons, and there were no hard stops; I used vinyl and cassettes at the same time, just as I used audio CDs and cassettes at the same time...

Gain unlimited access to Premium articles.

With technology shaping our everyday lives, how could we not dig deeper?

Thurrott Premium delivers an honest and thorough perspective about the technologies we use and rely on everyday. Discover deeper content as a Premium member.

Tagged with

Share post

Thurrott