What is happening with OneNote?

21

It seems like OneNote has been put on life support. Microsoft hasn’t added any new features to the product family in like 5 years! Also there is no clear vision for the future of the product. Is Microsoft moving away from OneNote or are they working on it all behind the scenes? It is getting insane photo cropping is still not an option.

Post Reply

Join the discussion!

BECOME A THURROTT MEMBER:

Don't have a login but want to join the conversation? Become a Thurrott Premium or Basic User to participate

Register
21 Comments
Sort by Votes | Date
  1. 1 | Reply
    Noteadviser - 3 weeks ago

    TheJoeFin has a point. Completely agree with you about the 9 points you raised above.

     

    Microsoft' strategy to focus on the UWP version of OneNote (multi platform) has certainly helped to broaden it's audience, and to catch up with Evernote (although I have no updated figure about that...).

    But Microsoft' roadmap for UWP is not crystal clear (although they focus so much on it) :

    - on one side they say they want UWP to get - some day - most of the desktop features,

    - but on the other side, they add features like ink replay and ink effects (rainbow, galaxy...) which aren't available in the desktop version, and are rather advertising gimmick (editable ink - released at the same time - with much less emphasis - has narrowed the gap between both version actually) ;

    - or they add such a feature like "Sharing Notifications Email service" (a pain in the a..) prior to solving single note (or single section) sharing (now on it's way...).

    More significantly, OneNote UWP' improvement could be more consistent with Microsoft' ink strategy : why including an Ink workspace in W10 anniversary (confusing, and poorly competing with OneNote...), and failing to add the ruler in OneNote ?!? A ruler is a killer feature which I was expecting to benefit from in OneNote : what a disapointment !!!

     

    As far as Desktop version is concerned, I have not noticed any significant improvement between 2013 and 2016 version (except Online video) :

    - insertion of PDF is still not possible, with Insert/File Printout

    - capture with the camera, although available in UWP, is still not present in the Desktop version

    - Integration with Office is still lagging behind (no OLE link with Excel for instance)

    - Linked notes don't work with Excel

     

    Sometimes I get the disturbing feeling that paying customers get less attention than free users !

    Is it only me ?

    1. 0 | Reply
      DBSync - 3 weeks ago
      In reply to Noteadviser:

      "insertion of PDF is still not possible, with Insert/File Printout"

      Not sure I understand what you mean by this. When I drag a PDF into my note it asks if I want to attach the file or Insert/File Printout. If I select Insert/File Printout it adds the actual printed document as well as the attached PDF.

    2. 0 | Reply
      Noteadviser - 3 weeks ago
      In reply to DBSync:

      I got an error message saying "There was a problem inserting the file. If you can open this file in another application, try printing the file to the "Send to OneNote 2016" printer instead.

      This error message appeared in OneNote 2013, and the same occurs in OneNote 2016 (although I can embed PDF file in OneNote sending them through the printer, as suggested).

      I though it would occur to anyone, meaning PDF was not supported with Insert/File (or the drag option you suggested), but I am happy (?) to hear that it's only me !

    3. 0 | Reply
      Noteadviser - 6 days ago
      In reply to DBSync:

      Your lack of understanding about my statement ("insertion of PDF is still not possible, with Insert/File Printout") made me think about it with a new perspective. Actually I found a may to make it work : install a desktop PDF reader (since a "Universal UI" reader is OK to open and annotate PDF, but is not enough to have this OneNote feature available in W10). Thanks for your comment, which help me fix this issue !

      For those having this issue, please refer to this blog post (https://onenote2016.wordpress.com/2016/11/30/insert-printout-issue-with-pdf/) for more explanation.

  2. 0 | Reply
    IronCondor Alpha Member #1246 - 3 weeks ago

    The one issue I see is taking photos in the OneNote Android APP. You have to select CAPTURE PHOTO, then save the phone, then take another photo, etc. With Evernote you can just snap pictures one of the other which helps when walking through a project site for example. If OneNote is updated with better photo capturing I would switch back. 

  3. 0 | Reply
    mike2k Alpha Member #1349 - 2 weeks ago

    I use it all the time for Logging my Weightlifting records/workouts, cooking recipies, Work items, and making quick notes is a great feature.  Because i use and like it so much, it will go the way of other MS products i loved and used, Technology Valhalla.  Zune, WMC, WHS, Band, Win Phone.....

  4. 0 | Reply
    innitrichie Alpha Member #1889 - 3 weeks ago

    I seem to be unlucky because whenever I try to use OneNote I almost immediately start running into unable to sync errors, where the recommend fix is delete and recreate and hope it works. (it rarely does, I then have to recreate the entire notebook - but eventually the sync errors comes back again)

    I love all the other Office stuff but OneNote has been an absolute nightmare for me in terms of reliability. I wouldn't care if they killed it off.

  5. 0 | Reply
    ccalberti - 3 weeks ago

    I have Office 365 for my small consulting buisiness and have weaned us off Evernote in favor of OneNote because of almost 100% overlap as to features (which seems to be front burner for MSFT's 365 team), excellent integration into Office products, and reliability on iOS platform for phones and iPads, our last Apple holdover.

  6. 0 | Reply
    lwetzel Alpha Member #113 - 3 weeks ago

    Anyone know of some place I might find templates and suggestions on using OneNote as a personal tool?  I mean I am retired but not dead.

  7. 0 | Reply
    jterwilligerii - 3 weeks ago

    What do you want it to have ? I use it constantly.  .  .desktop, UWC, web app and Android app. There have also been many recent improvements related to education purposes. Class notebook alone is amazing. There are also the new learning tools. I would however love to see the functionality of the desktop app nice  over to the other platforms. 

  8. 0 | Reply
    FalseAgent - 4 weeks ago

    They did mention at one point that they didn't want users to have to choose between OneNote 2016 and UWP OneNote, so if I were to guess, OneNote 2016 is getting killed in favour of UWP OneNote.

  9. 0 | Reply
    nightmare99 Alpha Member #1133 - 4 weeks ago

    The mobile apps are getting a lot of features, I think this is currently where the effort is going.

  10. 0 | Reply
    Wizzwith Alpha Member #2111 - 4 weeks ago

    Ummm... it's a completely mature product, what do you expect?  They are still adding features, they just aren't all hugely visible.  Some new things are not directly in the product but additions to the browser add ons etc.  

    1. 1 | Reply
      TheJoeFin Alpha Member #227 - 4 weeks ago
      In reply to Wizzwith:

      Except it is not completely mature when compared to all other Office programs. Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and Outlook see feature additions and improvements every month, but OneNote is left in the cold.

  11. 0 | Reply
    NazmusLabs - 4 weeks ago

    If you mean the desktop app, then I hate to be the bearer of bad news. Microsoft is focusing on the UWP app. I wouldn't be surprised to see the desktop app killed in a couple of years or so.

    1. 0 | Reply
      TheJoeFin Alpha Member #227 - 4 weeks ago
      In reply to NazmusLabs:

      I know they are focusing on the Win10 app, which is fine. However there doesn't seem to be any vision or roadmap for the Win10 app. It is still way behind the desktop app, and is missing features from even the iOS app. It just seems like Microsoft does not care about this product.

    2. 0 | Reply
      Edward_Grego - 4 weeks ago
      In reply to TheJoeFin:

      What features are you missing, I think Onenote is just a feature filled as all other office apps.

    3. 0 | Reply
      TheJoeFin Alpha Member #227 - 4 weeks ago
      In reply to Edward_Grego:
      • The Add-in model was changed on all the Office programs except OneNote,
      • No image crop tool.
      • No way to tie ink to images or text.
      • No custom styles.
      • No commenting support.
      • No modern collaboration support (seeing other users editing).
      • PDF annotation support is still buggy.
      • Sync performance is frequently lackluster.
      • It doesn't talk to the new universal OneDrive sync client for SharePoint credentials.
      • and more

       

      to list a few.

    4. 0 | Reply
      DBSync - 3 weeks ago
      In reply to TheJoeFin:

      I am in OneNote right now and selected an image, right clicked and selected crop. Is there something I am missing.

    5. 0 | Reply
      Noteadviser - 3 weeks ago
      In reply to DBSync:

      Which version are you using ? Mine is OneNote 2016 with an Office 365 family subscription, and - except which a 3rd party add-in called Onetastic - I definitely cannot crop images.

      Would you please include a screen capture ? 

      Thanks

    6. 0 | Reply
      TheJoeFin Alpha Member #227 - 3 weeks ago
      In reply to DBSync:

      If you added OneTastic it give cropping, but it is not native and the images loses resolution