Microsoft Surface Book with Performance Base: Gaming First Impressions

Posted on January 27, 2017 by Paul Thurrott in Games, Microsoft Surface with 6 Comments

Microsoft Surface Book with Performance Base: Gaming First Impressions

While most will not purchase Surface Book with Performance Base for gaming, this capability is indeed among the several major advantages it has over its predecessors.

No, really.

The Surface Book website barely mentions games or gaming, but it does do so. But our best indication that Surface Book with Performance Base does indeed target the gaming market came at the product announcement, which you’ll recall happened at Microsoft’s October 2016 Windows 10 Creators Update event.

At the time, Panos Panay indicated that this product was the result of customer feedback, though I suspect part of it was timing, too. (In that a second-generation Surface Book wouldn’t appear for at least several more months.) And some of that feedback was from gamers.

“Gamers … want more frame rate,” he said. They just want it. I don’t really get it, but they … They want it.”

OK, so he’s not a gamer. And one could argue that the level of understanding or caring he has about this topic is similar to what he showed for the Lumia 950 at the Microsoft event from a year earlier. But whatever. Surface is finally making its first real push into gaming.

It’s important to understand that the top half of Surface Book—the screen/tablet, or what Microsoft calls the Clipboard—has not changed. This is the same Core i7 processor, the same RAM, the same SSD storage we saw previously. Only the bottom base, where the dedicated graphics processor (dGPU) and the second battery resides, has changed.

It is this new dGPU that makes Surface Book with Performance Base more viable as a games machine than its predecessor. Those original Surface Book dGPU models could play games, as I discovered, but you really had to turn down the graphics quality to get acceptable frame rates. And as I’ve since discovered on more recent games, even titles like Batman: The Telltale Series, which one would think aren’t that graphically demanding, really bog down the earlier Surface Book models.

But the new dGPU offers “two times more graphics,” Panay says, “doubling the performance.” This new dGPU required a “full thermal redesign,” Panay said, one that distributes hot air to the back of the base using two fans—up from one in previous models—and “hyperbolic cooling fins.”

So observations about the cooling—by which I mean the fan noise—will certainly factor into my coming review. But the focus here today is on gaming. And this one is fairly simple: Do games play better on Surface Book with Performance Base? Meaning, do they offer better graphical fidelity and better performance in the form of higher frame rates and glitch-free game play?

A sub-page about Surface Book innovation on the Surface website says it will. “The new Surface Book with Performance Base also has the graphics power you need to play many of your favorite Xbox and PC games. Simply connect a Bluetooth-supported Xbox Wireless Controller and enjoy your down time.”

Challenge accepted.

I’ve done a few early tests so far, and the results are clearly positive. Games that looked horrible on previous Surface Book dGPU models—like Gears of War 4—now look wonderful on Surface Book with Performance Base, and viewing the same introductory videos and playing the same levels, you can really see a big difference. Even the menu screens look and perform better.

I mentioned Batman: The Telltale Series, and how the performance of this game was surprisingly lackluster on previous Surface Book dGPU models. With Performance Base, this game looks great and plays great, with none of the graphical glitching or pauses that dogged me before.

More testing is needed, I know.

So I’ve installed a number of games on this system—Forza Horizon 3Forza Motorsport 6, Minecraft: Windows 10 Edition, Quantum BreakRise of the Tomb Raider, and Valiant Hearts: The Great War, in addition to the previously-noted titles—and will do benchmark comparisons between it and my previous Surface Book with dGPU. I’ll be using the GeForce Experience application to auto-configure games for optimal performance and see how that differs between the two. And yes, I’ll be looking at Game mode in the Windows 10 Creators Update to see how/whether that improves matters.

But even at this early date, I can already see a very real difference. And while the NVIDIA GeForce GTX 965M dGPU that Microsoft is using in Surface Book with Performance Base isn’t necessarily leading edge, it really is a big step up from the previous dGPU. And appears to be good enough for many modern games.

More soon.

 

Tagged with

Join the discussion!

BECOME A THURROTT MEMBER:

Don't have a login but want to join the conversation? Become a Thurrott Premium or Basic User to participate

Register
Comments (6)

6 responses to “Microsoft Surface Book with Performance Base: Gaming First Impressions”

  1. Avatar

    4610

    I sure would like to upgrade my SB with a Performance Base.

     

    Pretty irritated that I can't...

  2. Avatar

    250

    I like the idea of the extra power available with the Performance Base, but I won't replace my original SB just to get access to it. I might be willing to spring for the Performance Base by itself it it turns out to work and play well with the existing clipboard. I know Microsoft declines to sell the base alone, but I don't know if that is just a marketing decision or whether there are engineering reasons not to mix the two parts.  Paul, if you take requests on compatibility determination, maybe you could try this with your review unit and report back. I would assume different drivers are involved for different chips, so I recognize that you might not want to try adapting your current clipboard to the new base. But if you're game...

    Glad to hear that you find the 965 GPU is powerful enough to produce a satisfactory gaming experience. I had the feeling that the original antipathy to the use of the 965 and 980 in the Surface Studio models was based more on spec table comparison than real world testing and evaluation. I agree that a 1080 will be better than something with less processing power, but how much excess capacity is really needed when something a little smaller is good enough? The Studio isn't a gaming machine either, but could certainly be used as one if a high-end and even more expensive box is not available.

    I can predict the reply that for serious gamers, nothing is ever good enough and a better processor is always wanted as well as warranted. But over here in this corner of the room, outside of the reality distortion field, something less than maximum is frequently found to be more than enough to do the job at hand.

  3. Avatar

    1631

    That's because Batman Telltale Series is incompetently optimized, just like all Telltale games.

  4. Avatar

    6852

    "So I’ve installed a number of games on this system—Forza Horizon 3, Forza Motorsport 6, Minecraft: Windows 10 Edition, Quantum Break, Rise of the Tomb Raider, and Valiant Hearts: The Great War, in addition to the previously-noted titles—and will do benchmark comparisons between it and my previous Surface Book with dGPU. I’ll be using the GeForce Experience application to auto-configure games for optimal performance and see how that differs between the two. And yes, I’ll be looking at Game mode in the Windows 10 Creators Update to see how/whether that improves matters."

    Awesome, can't wait to read what you find. Thanks for doing this testing on what is after all a pretty niche product.

  5. Avatar

    245

    Paul - 

     

    I thought you said that you would try to *enjoy* yourself.  Based on your GoW4 review, I would doubt that this experience was enjoyable! 

     

    ;-)

  6. Avatar

    7046

    Surface Book 2 will be released by the time you finish reviewing this one. 

Leave a Reply