Ex-Microsoftie Explains How the Firm Lost Windows (Premium)

James Whittaker has left Microsoft, and my does he have stories to tell. And when it comes to Windows, he gets it right.

Whittaker’s tell-all, available on Medium, hits on a number of topics, some of which will be familiar to readers of my Programming Windows series, which hits on just how terrible Bill Gates and his company were in the 1990s, in particular.

I’ll touch on some of that in a bit. But what I’m more interested in is his hot take on Windows. Some may recall that I was asked in a recent Ask Paul about me describing today’s Windows team as “b-teamers.”

“Windows phone … started out with some of the best minds at the company, folks who had worked on Windows for many years in many cases,” I wrote. “But as the platform stalled, all the good people left. The only people still working directly on Windows phone at the end were, largely, the B-teamers I refer to. Terry Myerson, as you may know, replaced the ultimate B-teamer, Andy Lees, when he took over that team; Lees didn’t know his own product particularly well, and I recall being astonished by this at the Windows Phone 8 launch in New York. Just a total bozo. When Terry took over Windows, he did what Sinofsky had done by replacing key people with his own people; over time, virtually everyone who had previously relied on Sinofsky for their career successes, deserved or not, was out. (The one major exception? Panos Panay.) But by that point, all the key players from the old Windows days were gone. What Terry had was … B-teamers. And that’s what came to Windows. You can think of it as multiple levels of sifting, where less and less good is left by the end.”

Here is what Whittaker says to this topic. It’s part of a broader discussion around the new culture at Microsoft under Satya Nadella, who quite obviously doesn’t care all that much about Windows, which is tied to the old Microsoft (Gates’ Microsoft), and will never be part of his legacy.

“It’s worth noting that cultural transformation didn’t happen in places, like Windows, where Nadella simply rearranged the made-men deck chairs,” he writes. “Instead of following his culture-change playbook, he simply swapped Windows’ made-men with Windows Phone’s made-men. The same people unable, over the course of a decade, to craft a winning strategy for mobile were suddenly tasked with crafting a winning strategy for the desktop. The unsurprising result is that Windows continues its tradition of boring, buggy software and consistently fumbled updates. [The emphasis there is mine. --Paul] Made-men aren’t fixable, and the real talent in Windows, and the diversity of ideas it possesses, remains anonymously buried under layers of made-men above it.”

Made men is an interesting term, and it’s obviously supposed to evoke the Mafia. But what he’s really describing is b-teamers, guys who are lifers who have jobs because they have jobs and can’t be touched. He’s describing b-tea...

Gain unlimited access to Premium articles.

With technology shaping our everyday lives, how could we not dig deeper?

Thurrott Premium delivers an honest and thorough perspective about the technologies we use and rely on everyday. Discover deeper content as a Premium member.

Tagged with

Share post

Please check our Community Guidelines before commenting

Windows Intelligence In Your Inbox

Sign up for our new free newsletter to get three time-saving tips each Friday

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Thurrott © 2024 Thurrott LLC