Surface Laptop 2 vs MacBook Air

Posted on October 31, 2018 by Brad Sams in Brad, Podcasts with 18 Comments

Looking at buying a new Surface Laptop 2 or MacBook Air? Here’s what you need to know.

RSS | SoundCloud | YouTube | iTunes | Google Play



Tagged with ,

Join the discussion!

BECOME A THURROTT MEMBER:

Don't have a login but want to join the conversation? Become a Thurrott Premium or Basic User to participate

Register
Comments (18)

18 responses to “Surface Laptop 2 vs MacBook Air”

  1. Avatar

    wp7mango

    Does the Surface laptop have a touch screen? Because that would make it even better value than the Macbook Air.

  2. Avatar

    rmlounsbury

    The Surface Laptop 2 is pretty well superior in just about every respect. Especially in the processor department where the SL2 has U series processors instead of the Y series of the MacBook Air. The only real advantage the Air has is that it has 2 USB-C Thunderbolt 3 backed ports vs. the USB-A + Surface Connect ports.


    What is really amazing is the fact that Apple still offers the older version of the Air for $999. Talk about insulting.

  3. Avatar

    provision l-3

    Okay, so the "Apple priced this 200 dollars higher to get people to buy the iPad Pro" conspiracy is something you picked up from someone like Alex Jones right, cause that is just kinda ridiculous. Apple doesn't give a flying flip if you buy a MacBook Air or an iPad they just want you to buy one. Apple priced it that way because Apple thinks that is what the market care bare, no need for some sort of logical contortions. Hell, they even kept the old MacBook Air at the 999.00 price point. If they were worried about people buying Macs over laptops they would have just dropped it.


  4. Avatar

    Andi

    15W on the Surface vs 7W on the Air. This is the only diferentiator you need to know.

  5. Avatar

    Illusive_Man

    MacOS is a better OS. Windows has more available applications and better for gaming but MacOS, but the core OS sucks.

  6. Avatar

    Brazbit

    Another differentiator, though not as useful as in a 2:1, is the touchscreen on the Surface Laptop 2 vs a standard display on the MBA. Not a must-have feature, but a very nice to have feature for those interactions that lend themselves better to direct interaction with the screen. Plus, when you instinctually reach out and try to do something on the screen something actually happens and you are not left feeling like an idiot tapping on a non-touch screen. ;-)

  7. Avatar

    ruusterc

    so acouple things first of all i got a call you on batterylife thing because well on paper the surface laptop has better battery life in real world it gets about half of what its rated thats not me saying that thats reviewers in cluding i think even paul said that an air side whether you like apple or not there battery life estismates are usally spot on or a little under so battery life would be a win for the air because. the air gets 12 hrs of realworld and the surface book gets 8 or 9 hrs the other difference is the biggest reason why i dont think the surface laptop is a better value an i like the surface products an i wish the air had touch screen like the surface products do but the thing for me that makes the surface laptop not as much of a value is the fact that for example on stage they talked about hole disk encryption which is built in to mac os so thats great if i want to do that onthe surface laptop i have to upgrade to windows 10pro the cost of pro lisence is 169 dollars in canada so if you add that on to the 1299 price of the surface laptop in canada theres only about a 32.00 difference in price between the two the macbook air starts at 1499 the other thing is the ports so surface laptop has a usb a headphone jack an display port a proprietary charging and dock connector the macbook air supports usbc an a headphone jack tgis makes a difference as well because usbc can do video data an charging so if your power cable on your surface ever goes its about 80 dollars to replace the surface charger my macbook charger got stollen i bought a usb c brick which costed about 30 dollars and i already have a usb c cable the other thing is well they both require dongles for certain things the use of usb c means you dont have to buy apple expensive accessories you have a choice on the microsoft side you pretty much one option for docks an thats the microsft dock which is proprietary AF that dock is about 200 dollars but at the end of the day there both fantastic choices im a big fan of you an paul. keep up the good work

  8. Avatar

    drrjv

    I'm happy to be "stuck" in the Apple World

  9. Avatar

    cyloncat

    Also, touch screen on Surface Laptop. No touch screen or touch bar on the Air.


    On the other hand, it really does come down to ecosystem; established users will likely stay with what they currently use. Apple's retail channel is also a factor. Both Apple and Microsoft offer excellent retail experience, but Apple just has more stores.

  10. Avatar

    veroach

    Brad,


    One is a touch screen and one is not. How does that not factor for you in the displays? Huge difference for me.


    Eric

Leave a Reply