With the majority of the holiday shopping season now behind us, we can take a high-level look to see how various companies performed during the season. Specifically, when it comes to digital assistants, app installs are generally a good benchmark of performance.
Looking at both the iOS app store and Google Play, Amazon appears to have had a home run of a holiday season with its Alexa app topping charts for both platforms. Google has a Google Home app that is at the number 6 position for top free apps for iOS and number 2 position on Android, indicating that its hardware also sold well this year.
Sign up for our new free newsletter to get three time-saving tips each Friday — and get free copies of Paul Thurrott's Windows 11 and Windows 10 Field Guides (normally $9.99) as a special welcome gift!
"*" indicates required fields
There are also two other players, Microsoft and Apple and the story is quite clear here. Apple’s hardware isn’t available which means it missed out entirely and Microsoft doesn’t appear to have performed much better with Cortana not showing up on either app store top free list.
Amazon, who is clearly happy with the results, pushed out a press release saying they sold millions of more devices this year but they don’t provide any hard numbers. Google hasn’t said anything at this time but its performance in the app stores show that it sold quite a few devices as well.
What this means is that as of now, the smart speaker market is still a two-horse race with Amazon clearly leading but Google is making inroads. Cortana, with the Harman Kardon speaker, does not appear to be selling well this year which further plagues on Microsoft’s issue of expanding the assistant’s footprint outside of Windows 10.
I’ll be curious to see how well Apple can play in this market when they finally get their Home Pod out the door and of course for Microsoft, they seriously need to work on a new strategy here as this year was another failure for Cortana when compared to Alexa or Google’s products.
The strong sales were likely fueled by low-cost products like the Echo from Amazon and Home Mini from Google that can be found for under $30 whereas Microsoft’s only product with Cortana is at least $99 if you grab it on sale. Apple and Microsoft both have iOS/Windows to keep their fan base connected to their assistants but smart speakers are quickly showing that this method significantly increases engagement with the services.
The next few years will be critical for these digital assistants as ambient computing becomes more popular and while the race is far from over, Microsoft and Apple are finding themselves well-behind Amazon and Google. Apple will likely be ok in the long-term as it sells millions of iPhones every quarter which promotes the use of Siri but Microsoft, even with Windows 10 adoption growing, has yet to move Cortana outside the walls of the desktop OS with any meaningful success.
shameermulji
<blockquote><a href="#230984"><em>In reply to xapache:</em></a></blockquote><p>I watch NHL Hockey almost daily. Every smart-assistant product related ad pre-Christmas was for Google Home. EVERY ONE.</p>
Bats
<p>I don't understand the headline where it says that Amazon has pushed farther ahead. Where is the proof?</p><p><br></p><p>The Amazon Echo is great. I bought one for my aunt and uncle for this Christmas. However, the echo with Alexa is clearly not as smart as Google Home. Amazon is winning, because it has been in the market first. Amazon vs Google is a great prize fight. For me, it doesn't matter, because i have both. </p><p><br></p><p>To be honest, I don't even know why Microsoft entered this market. They had to know that they were going to lose. Like Windows Phone, you can't really do anything with the Invoke. I played with it at Best Buy and it's not super impressive. Think of it like this, when you're used to eating Wagyu Steak, eating a hamburger will make you close to throwing up. </p>
skane2600
<p>It's funny that Amazon, a company that is fundamentally in the retail business, has introduced more innovative technologies than many purely tech companies. Certainly more of a tech company than Facebook or twitter.</p>
skane2600
<blockquote><a href="#231098"><em>In reply to KingPCGeek:</em></a></blockquote><p>Any business that delivers a product is in the logistics business.</p>
shameermulji
<blockquote><a href="#231000"><em>In reply to yaddamaster:</em></a></blockquote><p>"I've often wondered what the next emerging consumer device would be after mobile. I think I now know."</p><p><br></p><p>I wouldn't count wearables out of that title race just yet, and I don't mean AR / VR, but more specifically devices like Apple Watch. Apple Watch has witnessed strong growth over the last couple of years and with Apple Watch 3 and its focus on health / fitness / LTE, interest has never been higher. The combination of Apple Watch / AirPods is one of the bright spots in the post-Steve Jobs Apple.</p>
Stooks
<blockquote><a href="#231055"><em>In reply to ozaz:</em></a></blockquote><p>Me too. I knew they had a device but did not know the name of it.</p>
Stooks
<blockquote><a href="#231000"><em>In reply to yaddamaster:</em></a></blockquote><p>Wow someone actually bought this??????</p><p><br></p><p>$99 would have bought A LOT of toilet paper.</p>