
When it comes to switching from Windows, there’s the Mac and then there’s everything else. Apple’s Mac is the only computer platform that rivals Windows across the board, and if you use other Apple products and services, the ecosystem benefits put it over the top. The learning curve is real, yes, but surmountable, and some perceived negatives, like cost, are a red herring.
The Mac is a viable computing platform for just about anyone, from consumers and casual users to developers and power users. The only notable exception is gaming: Despite excellent hardware and powerful graphics capabilities, the Mac has never been a viable gaming platform, with only sporadic support from developers and a lackluster overall experience. Windows remains the go-to for this audience, with Linux as a distant second.
There is now a Mac at just about every price point. Sticking to the portable solutions most people will consider, Apple now offers the following laptop families.
? MacBook Neo. With prices starting at $599, the 13-inch MacBook Neo is the newly affordable Mac, but it comes with too many compromises to recommend to mainstream users. Consider a MacBook Neo only if you are a casual computer user who very occasionally needs to write or perform other short tasks using a display larger than that on your phone and a real, full-sized keyboard. (An iPad with a Magic Keyboard would be a better solution for most, however.)
? MacBook Air. The MacBook Air is the right Mac for most people. It’s available in 13.6- and 15-inch models, offers powerful Apple Silicon M-series processors, 16 to 32 GB of RAM, and 512 GB to 2 TB of storage, and it comes in a thin, light, silent form factor while delivering the best battery life in the market. Prices start at $1099 for the 13.5-inch models and $1299 for the 15-inch models.
? MacBook Pro. Aimed at high-end creators and developers, the MacBook Pro is available in 14- and 16-inch models, offers the most powerful Apple Silicon M-series processors, and can be configured with 16 to 128 GB of RAM and 1 to 8 TB of storage. These are essentially portable workstations with dated form factors, and they are thick and heavy with loud fans. Prices start at $1699 for the 14-inch models and $2699 for the 16-inch models.
The price gap between the MacBook Neo and Air is artificially astronomical, but a refurbished MacBook Air M2 or newer processor can help lower the cost depending on availability, and it will be a better, more future-proof Mac than the Neo. And be sure to take advantage of Apple’s educational pricing if possible when you are buying new.
One of the issues with the Mac is that you will need to buy a new computer from Apple: Unlike with Linux and Chrome OS Flex, you can’t just install macOS on an existing PC. What you get in return for this expense is a far more consistent and polished experience that’s guaranteed to work well. But it also makes the Mac less enticing for those who wish to experiment on the side before potentially making a switch.
Apple, like Microsoft, is a Big Tech behemoth that abuses its customers by enshittifying some of its solutions. But the ecosystem benefits one gets from Apple still outweigh those issues, to my mind, and Apple hasn’t objectively enshittified the Mac in any way to date. (Some may or may not like the new Liquid Glass user interface that Apple added to all its major platforms, but that’s subjective and doesn’t get in the way of using a Mac.)
If you take a hardline stance on Big Tech or proprietary technologies, the Mac may not be for you. But if you’re tired of Microsoft’s abuses in Windows 11, the Mac serves as a reminder of what a customer-centric computer platform can be.
When it comes to compatibility across the hardware peripherals, software, and online services you rely on, it’s pretty much all there on the Mac. And that includes top-tier cloud storage services like Google Drive and Microsoft OneDrive: Unlike with Linux, these are natively supported on the Mac and, as important, provide the full range of functionality as do the Windows clients, with things like Files on Demand. (Google Drive is available on Chrome OS and Chrome OS Flex.)
Again, the big exception here is games. You can buy a handful of top-tier games from the Mac App Store, and even Steam offers some Mac-compatible games, though many require older Intel-based Macs. But for the most part, hardcore gamers will want to stick with Windows or maybe Linux. (Or an existing videogame console or mobile device, I suppose.)
Where Linux is nothing but challenges to even the most technical users, the Mac just works and that’s especially true for the less technical. That said, there are minor usage hurdles to overcome tied to familiarity–some things are just a bit different between Windows and the Mac–and Apple’s curious habit of thinking differently when it comes to the inconsistent and sometimes quirky design of its software and services.
Most of this is minor. For example, the Mac uses a system-wide menu instead of letting apps handle that. There’s a Dock instead of a Taskbar, and it has some different behaviors. And the Mac has different keyboard keys and shortcuts than Windows (and Linux and Chrome OS/Chrome OS). Instead of typing Ctrl + C to copying an item to the clipboard, you type Cmd + C on the Mac, and that Cmd key is in a different location than the Ctrl key on other keyboards.
There are also some differences in window management and multitasking that might be offputting. The Mac supports window positioning and sizing normally, for the most part, but it also adds a mobile device-like Full Screen mode that is, in some ways, nice but also adds a bit of complexity. And you can close an app window (say, with Cmd + W) but that won’t close the app (Cmd + Q), even if it was the only open app window.
Likewise, the Mac Finder feels antiquated compared to File Explorer in Windows, and it intermingles folders and files alphabetically, unlike in Windows, where folders are always at the top of a folder display, above the files. This is neither better nor worse, it’s just different.
But the biggest issue, to me, is that the Mac doesn’t put all app windows in the Cmd + Tab app switching interface, like Microsoft does in Windows with Alt + Tab; you have to look in a Window menu to see other windows used by the same app. There’s no viable solution to this in the system, so I overcome this problem with a third-party utility called AltTab. Now, Cmd + Tab actually works.
One of the best reasons to buy a Mac is that you may already have an iPhone and, accordingly, some combination of iPad, Apple Watch, HomePod speakers, and whatever other Apple devices. And as so many Apple users know and love, these devices interoperate in ways that are so seamless that it will seem magical to most of us stuck in Windows. This integration extends to Apple’s services, which are largely designed for consumers, including families, and not businesses.
There are too many integrations to list, but here are a few key examples. You can copy any item to the clipboard on an iPhone or iPad and then copy it on your Mac to achieve the simplest of cross-device copying. You can attach an iPad to your Mac and use it as a secondary computer display. And you can use an Apple Watch to unlock your iPhone, iPad, or Mac; that’s particularly useful for the latter as the Mac doesn’t support FaceID for some reason.
On the services side, Apple offers free and paid iCloud storage, and it has various standalone consumer services–Apple Music, Apple TV, Apple Arcade, and several others–that can also be subscribed to in Apple One bundles that can be shared between multiple users in a family (if you go for the Family or Premier tiers). This can save a lot of money for those with multiple Apple using family members.
When I think about Apple and the relationship it has with its customers, I see some sharp differences with the experience in Windows. Where Microsoft is focused on business customers to the detriment of consumers, Apple cares only about individuals and families. And you can see that different focus in the hardware, software, and services it offers.
Yes, there are some bad behaviors in the Apple ecosystem, from onerous App Store fees to anticompetitive behavior, but users are largely shielded from these issues, where they receive the brunt of Microsoft’s most egregious behaviors in Windows.
The Mac isn’t perfect, and there’s a “grass is always greener” effect to worry about, as you may be trading some frustrations for new frustrations when switching. But the Mac is the only computer platform that can replace Windows fully, and the benefits of that broad and deep ecosystem will make it a no-brainer for many.
That said, there is one major downside to the Apple ecosystem: It’s a one-way, dead-end street. You’ll have the best experience if you go all-in on Apple, and that may mean giving up on an Android smartphone and smartwatch, or whatever, leading to additional switching costs. You can try to resist, I suppose, or switch over time. But you have to pay to enter the Apple ecosystem and there is no problem within that cannot be solved without paying even more.
Pros
✔️ The only platform that meets or exceeds Windows 11 point-by-point
✔️ Apple ecosystem puts the Mac over the top
✔️ Broadly compatible with the apps and services you use every day
Cons
❌ You have to buy a new computer
❌ Numerous small differences will require some relearning
❌ A non-starter for gamers
❌ You may end up buying additional Apple devices for the best experience
With technology shaping our everyday lives, how could we not dig deeper?
Thurrott Premium delivers an honest and thorough perspective about the technologies we use and rely on everyday. Discover deeper content as a Premium member.