Microsoft Surface Dial Review

Microsoft Surface Dial Review

While Microsoft’s new Surface Dial is high on promise, it’s probably best suited for Surface Studio and its voluminous screen for now.

I write “probably” because Microsoft has ignored my months of begging for a review unit. I think we can all safely assume it’s awesome—it had better be, given the price tag—but I won’t know for sure until Microsoft takes pity on a poor reviewer or I hit the lottery. Neither is expected anytime soon. (To be fair to Microsoft, Surface Studio is simply in very short supply. Maybe “ignoring” was a bit harsh, and “dealing with my complaints” is more accurate.)

Windows Intelligence In Your Inbox

Sign up for our new free newsletter to get three time-saving tips each Friday — and get free copies of Paul Thurrott's Windows 11 and Windows 10 Field Guides (normally $9.99) as a special welcome gift!

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

So what I’m left with is the standalone Surface Dial, which anyone can purchase for $100 from the Microsoft Store. I’m having trouble coming up with a good reason to do so.

For those unfamiliar with this unassuming little peripheral, Microsoft markets Surface Dial as a completely new kind of PC interface. But unlike a mouse or smart pen, Surface Dial is meant to be used alongside another peripheral—most typically Microsoft’s own Surface Pen—where you have one in each hand. That is, it’s not a standalone tool, nor is it something you switch back and forth to.

Dual-wielding PC peripherals isn’t all that common, even among the graphics professionals who might use Wacom tablets and other similar industry-specific hardware inputs. So Surface Dial requires a bit of adjustment, if not outright training for most.

It also requires a pretty big screen to be used effectively, which explains my Surface Studio comment earlier. (That device has a 28-inch screen.) That’s because, like a pen, you’ll typically place the Surface Dial right on the screen. So you could use it with a Surface Book or even a Surface Pro 4, I guess. But it’s not great.

You don’t have to use it right on the screen, and in fact you could simply pair the device to any Bluetooth-based PC. In this case—without a compatible Surface device—Surface Dial is reduced to its most basic usage. That is, you can adjust the system volume at any time, or perform a few other basic functions if an app is selected.

If you press and hold on the top of Surface Dial, a radial menu will appear onscreen. What you see in this menu depends on what is selected on-screen. On the desktop, only a Volume option is provided in the menu, so when you rotate the dial, it adjusts the volume up or down. You can also press once to toggle mute.

If an application—Word, MarkdownPad, Paint, whatever—is selected, the menu has more choices: Volume, Scroll (which is now the default), Zoom, and Undo. So you can change, on the fly, which function the dial uses. (And some features, like Zoom, work better in certain apps, of course.)

But some apps have been updated with explicit Surface Dial support, and these apps provide additional options in that menu. You can findthe compatible apps listed on the device’s product page.

Maps is a good example: It supports Zoom, Rotate and Tilt features, so you can adjust the view of the map with Dial.

Groove Music supports scrolling and song scrubbing.

You gain a few things when you use Surface Dial on a (Surface) screen. For starters, the basic dial menu features both volume and brightness options now. And the device is context-sensitive when used with Surface displays; that is, Dial reports its on-screen location back to apps that have been written to support this feature.

I haven’t really been able to test that feature per se—I’m not aware of an app that supports it—but I could at least test pen-sensitive apps like Sketchpad (part of the Windows Ink Workspace in Windows 10), which provides additional dial menu options like Pens and Size, enabling a brief glimpse at what two-hand operation—Surface Pen on the right, Dial on the left—is like.

In short, I’m not sure I can recommend this device for Surface Book or Surface Pro users yet, and those without Surface devices should absolutely skip Surface Dial for now. But support for Dial can only improve over time, and I suspect—since, again, I don’t have one—that it works well in tandem with Surface Studio and more professional apps than the ones I’ve used.

Tagged with

Share post

Please check our Community Guidelines before commenting

Conversation 17 comments

  • 5664

    Premium Member
    17 January, 2017 - 11:58 am

    <p>I’m hoping more affordable options for multitouch displays appear, with their own Windows wheel peripherals. The Dell Canvas looks nice, but seeing as I don’t need it for pro graphics use, I also don’t need HiDPI or wide-gamut color for writing, audio editing, and media consumption.</p>
    <p>I’d honestly love a 20-23" 1920×1080 or 1920×1200 multitouch consumer-level convertible screen. I’ve got a quad-core i7 box, I’d love to be able to use it in full touch mode!</p>

  • 1217

    17 January, 2017 - 11:59 am

    <p>As a developer, I’m curious to see if this device will ever be incorporated into Visual Studio/VSCode, and if so, for what contexts. &nbsp;I like the idea for its intended initial audience, but can it be configured to make debugging easier? &nbsp;Or finding branches? &nbsp;Managing source code? &nbsp;I don’t know. &nbsp;But I’m curious to see if a story arises here, and what that story would be.</p>

    • 427

      17 January, 2017 - 4:18 pm

      <blockquote><em><a href="#37014">In reply to </a><a href="../../../users/nordyj">nordyj</a><a href="#37014">:</a></em></blockquote>
      <blockquote><em>There was an experiment done with this at one of the MVP Summits.&nbsp; I want to be able to write code for it. But it ONLY works with Surface devices. </em></blockquote>

  • 6844

    17 January, 2017 - 12:38 pm

    <p>This would really shine for people doing a lot of scrubbing through video/animation.</p>

  • 10079

    17 January, 2017 - 12:45 pm

    <blockquote><em><a href="#37014">In reply to </a><a href="../../../users/nordyj">nordyj</a><a href="#37014">:</a></em>&nbsp;Have you seen this?;?</blockquote>

  • 4800

    Premium Member
    17 January, 2017 - 1:08 pm

    <p>I setup the custom feature to increase and decrease the brush size in Photoshop. &nbsp;I use it with the Surface Book with the keyboard flipped so I have the pen in one hand and the dial in the other. &nbsp;I generally have the dial like where a mouse would be instead of on the screen. &nbsp;It works well. &nbsp;I just wish Photoshop had better support for it.</p>

  • 5531

    17 January, 2017 - 1:39 pm

    <p>Looks like something that could be useful if it was integrated with NLE software&nbsp;</p>

  • 7317

    17 January, 2017 - 2:31 pm

    <p>I think it might be a pretty cool control to use with audio editing software.</p>

    • 9562

      17 January, 2017 - 3:36 pm

      <blockquote><em><a href="#37118">In reply to </a><a href="../../../users/DaveMcLain">DaveMcLain</a><a href="#37118">:</a></em></blockquote>
      <p>Scrub/jog wheels are nothing new. &nbsp;This would be overpriced for that function anyway.</p>

      • 5530

        17 January, 2017 - 5:42 pm

        <blockquote><em><a href="#37175">In reply to </a><a href="../../../users/BoItmanLives">BoItmanLives</a><a href="#37175">:</a></em></blockquote>
        <p>Those are nothing new, but a universal kind of control that does other things and doubles as a scrub is something new.</p>

  • 1561

    Premium Member
    17 January, 2017 - 3:00 pm

    <p>I’m&nbsp;unclear. Have they actually released the Surface firmware update that allows the Dial to work by placing it directly on the screen yet? I bought a Surface Dial right after it came out, and while it’s an interesting peripheral for my Surface Pro 4, the inability to actually place it on the screen has proven a bit limiting.</p>

    • 2

      Premium Member
      17 January, 2017 - 3:12 pm

      <blockquote><em><a href="#37142">In reply to </a><a href="../../../users/gregsedwards">gregsedwards</a><a href="#37142">:</a></em></blockquote>
      <p>Oh, maybe not. I was never able to test that, but wasn’t&nbsp;sure what the reason was.</p>

    • 4800

      Premium Member
      17 January, 2017 - 6:34 pm

      <blockquote><em><a href="#37142">In reply to </a><a href="../../../users/gregsedwards">gregsedwards</a><a href="#37142">:</a></em></blockquote>
      <p>I think the on screen stuff only works on the Surface Studio. &nbsp;I’m guessing they need something in the screen for it to work.</p>

  • 7156

    17 January, 2017 - 9:35 pm

    <p>What is the advantage of placing the Dial on the screen, rather than just your desk? It is more likely&nbsp;that the Dial will hide parts&nbsp;of the radial menu from your view.</p>
    <p>If you are using 2 applications&nbsp;snapped side by side, do you need to lift the Dial off the screen and then place it on the other&nbsp;side of the screen to use it on the other application?</p>
    <p>Couldn’t this all be done with the&nbsp;mouse scroll wheel, rather than buy a $100 peripheral that has a very limited use?</p>

  • 1753

    Premium Member
    18 January, 2017 - 2:14 am

    <p>Dual input is very common, when working on graphics, although it is usually pen/mouse and keyboard.</p>
    <p>When doing large edits, I tend to have the pen in one hand and the other hovering over the keyboard switching pen context as I go.</p>

  • 218

    Premium Member
    18 January, 2017 - 12:36 pm

    <p>I use it with my Surface Pro 4, for the basic functions listed above. Like gregsedwards mentioned as of today 1/18/2016 still no support for the dial onscreen.&nbsp; However, I’ve been spoiled using the scrolling function when browsing the web, in applications like Tweetium, etc. It’s a lot easier then spinning the wheel on a mouse or hitting the scroll bar on the screen.&nbsp; It’s a lot more precise and I keep mine on the left side of my keyboard so that my mouse hand gets a break when I’m doing a lot of scrolling/reading.&nbsp; I also like it when I have Groove running as it’s a quick way to adjust the volume and mute during client calls and such.&nbsp; Yeah, at $99 it’s a bit of overkill, but so far I’ve been happy with the purchase.</p>

  • thea2_

    Premium Member
    25 September, 2017 - 9:44 am

    <p>seeing that Brad has the surface studio why isn't he doing the review?</p>

Windows Intelligence In Your Inbox

Sign up for our new free newsletter to get three time-saving tips each Friday

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Thurrott © 2024 Thurrott LLC