HP Spectre x2 (2017) Review

Posted on July 28, 2017 by Paul Thurrott in Hardware, Windows 10 with 27 Comments

HP Spectre x2 (2017) Review

HP’s new Spectre x2 is like Surface Pro, but better: It offers a superior and more modern design, and is a better value, thanks to lower pricing and the inclusion of a type cover and active pen.

What’s not to love?

Design

If you’ve been paying attention to HP’s premium PCs in recent years, you know that the firm has moved to a gorgeous new dark ash silver and copper color scheme that really differentiates its products. Design is, of course, subjective. But I find these devices to be the prettiest in the business. They scream premium in ways that corporate-looking ThinkPads and bland Dell XPS laptops do not.

The x2’s body is CNC-machined, which means that it has been milled from a single piece of aluminum for rigidity and stability. The color, on both the body and the kickstand, is actually a coating, which in the case of the chassis is anodized. But I’ve not experienced any obvious scratches or marks as I saw on the Surface Laptop.

As important, the application of HP’s premium color scheme has reached a new apex on the x2, with the copper accent found basically only on the elegant new kickstand, providing just the right amount of visual oomph. Some early versions of this scheme, like the Spectre laptop, were a bit too gaudy for many. But the Spectre x2 gets it just right.

That kickstand has been improved immeasurably over the original design, and it no longer requires a hard-to-use slider switch to release it. Too, the U-shaped design, which initially seems a bit too thin to work well, allows HP to cram more battery into the body since it takes up so little space when closed. It even helps the device stand up a little straighter vertically, an issue I had with the previous device.

The kickstand also allows the x2 to tilt back to 165 degrees, a huge improvement over the previous version that matches the new Surface Pro’s so-called Studio mode. Pushed back this far, the x2 provides an ideal surface (ahem) for writing or drawing with the bundled active pen.

Put simply, this is a beautiful device, and it is arguably the best-looking 2-in-1 in the market. But the design is also more practical now, and the device is easier to use than before.

Display

While HP has improved the 2017 Spectre x2 in a variety of ways compared to its predecessor, its new display is perhaps the biggest single improvement. It is certainly the most noticeable.

The previous generation x2 provided a 12-inch 1080p-ish display with a strange 1920 x 1280 resolution and that 3:2 aspect ratio that is perfect for 2-in-1s. For 2017, HP has significantly improved this display. It’s a bit bigger, at 12.3 inches, but thanks to the smaller bezels, it sits in an even smaller body. And the resolution is now 3000 x 2000, or what HP calls 3K2K. And in case it’s not obvious, yes, it’s still 3:2.

And it is gorgeous, and not only because of the dramatically improved pixel density. The new display is also significantly brighter than the version it replaces and it delivers much richer colors.

Components and ports

Speaking of yesteryear, you may recall that the original x2 was dogged by poorly-performing Intel Core M processors. For this generation, HP has wisely pushed upward to 7th generation Core i5 and Core i7 processors with Intel Iris Plus 640 graphics. The device also offers up to 16 GB of fast LPDDR3 RAM and up to 1 TB of fast PCIe-based SSD storage.

Externally, the x2 presents some interesting compromises. It offers two USB-C ports, one on each side, and of course, it utilizes USB-C charging.

But those ports aren’t Thunderbolt 3-capable, so they are limited to just 5 Gbs of bandwidth. So that’s something to consider if you intend to dock it or use external displays. Likewise, the x2 is so thin that HP doesn’t include even a single full-sized USB 3 port. But it at least includes a dongle for compatibility with existing peripherals. The x2 also includes a microSD slot for storage expansion.

So how does this all come together?

On paper, the Spectre x2 falls short of the 2017 Ultrabook norm from a performance perspective. It required 2 hours and 14 minutes to encode the 4K video Tears of Steel to 1080p using the Handbrake utility. This is the longest time I’ve measured this year: The ThinkPad X1 Carbon and HP Spectre x360 15 (2017), for example, both required about 1 hour and 40 minutes.

But that’s a fairly grueling and test, and an esoteric need. In real world use, the Spectre x2 delivers fantastic performance for the productivity tasks that it was designed to handle. And I never noticed any slowdowns, stutters, or glitches while using my standard suite of tools, which includes Microsoft Office, Google Chrome, and Adobe Photoshop Elements.

The x2 does exhibit a fairly regular fan hiss, which wouldn’t normally be notable in a device this thin. But given the magic of the nearly silent Surface Pro (2017), the hiss is worth mentioning, and is a downside. Likewise, the back of the x2 can get hot, though the tablet form factor means that the heat will be exposed to the air, and not muffled (or exacerbated) by whatever surface the device is resting on.

I’m surprised to report that audio playback, normally a tinny and lackluster experience on tablets and 2-in-1s, is surprisingly solid. HP says it has improved the audio compared to the previous model by utilizing front-firing speakers, and via its collaboration with Bang & Olufsen. Whatever the reason, audio is crisp, clear, and bright. And surprisingly loud.

Keyboard, touchpad, and pen

As with other 2-in-1 PCs, the HP Spectre x2 utilizes a cover that magnetically connects to the device’s tablet body and provides both a keyboard and a touchpad. But there are differences between the HP solution and those of its rivals, especially the new Surface Pro.

For starters, this keyboard cover is included in the price of the x2, whereas Microsoft charges $160 for its most comparable keyboard cover, the Signature Type Cover.

But it’s not just the price: The x2 keyboard cover offers the best typing experience I’ve ever had with a 2-in-1 PC. And it more closely emulates the key feel and feedback that one expects from a traditional Ultrabook or laptop keyboard. Yes, there’s a bit of flex if you look for it—just press down on the center of the keyboard—but in normal use, it’s nearly flawless with aluminum-coated keys and an ideal 1.5 mm of key travel.

Thanks to the 3:2 aspect ratio of the display and device itself, the wrist rest area is a bit shorter than with 16:9 or 16:10 PCs, but I never found that to be an issue over two trips with the device. And the cover supports two typing angles, thanks to the magic of magnets, just like Surface Pro.

The touchpad is wide, like those on other HP portable PCs, but I didn’t experience many unwelcome mis-clicks.

Finally, the keyboard cover has a nice, grippy exterior surface for a more secure grip while moving the device around. It’s just a great accessory all around.

HP also bundles an active pen with the Spectre x2, which is a nice touch. (That’s a $100 extra with the new Surface Pro.) And the pen experience is pretty great, thanks in part to the x2’s new found ability to tilt back to 165 degrees. The pen itself hasn’t improved this year, however, so it offers 1024 pressure sensitivity levels, not 4096 like Surface Pen, and it doesn’t support tilt. Long story short, the pen performance is excellent, but it is out-classed by the silky smooth new Surface Pen, especially when paired with the new Surface Pro.

But here’s a final win for HP: The Spectre x2 includes an integrated pen loop so you can securely carry your pen with you. Can I get a hallelujah?

Battery

The HP Spectre x2 delivered 8 hours and 18 minutes of life on my 1080p video streaming tests over Wi-Fi. So it came in roughly identical to Lenovo’s 2017 ThinkPad X1 Carbon, which delivered 8:14 and utilizes very similar components, aside from the displays: The HP features a 12.3-inch display at 3000 x 2000 pixels, whereas the X1 utilizes a larger 14-display, albeit at a much lower 1080p resolution.

Software

After making some big gains towards cleaner PC images in past years, HP has reverted to its old ways. Like all HPs, the x2 includes the reviled and time-limited McAfee security software, which I recommend removing immediately. But it also ships with a strange assortment of utilities and outright crapware that goes above and beyond the crap that Microsoft already includes in Windows 10.

There is, for example, a superfluous password manager called Keeper, some games, and a strangely huge assortment of HP software like Bang & Olufsen Audio Control, HP Audio Switch, HP ePrint SW, HP Support Assistant, HO Documentation, HP Recovery Manager, HP Recovery Media Creation, HP JumpStart, HP Orbit, HP Pen Control, and probably others. Much of this is redundant, and surely there is a way to clean it all up.

The one utility you’ll want to become familiar with is the HP Support Assistant: It will help you download x2-specific drivers and other software updates. But it’s not as clean and easy to use as, say, the Lenovo Companion app that comes with the ThinkPad X1 Carbon.

The Spectre x2 ships with Windows 10 Home.

Pricing and configurations

The Spectre x2 can be had for as little as $1150 for a model with a Core i5 processor, 8 GB of RAM, and a smallish 128 GB of SSD storage. But remember that this includes that stunning 3000 x 2000 3:2 display, the excellent keyboard cover, and the active pen. With the new Surface Pro, you pay extra for the keyboard cover and pen, and a similarly configured Microsoft device would cost $1259; and that Surface only includes 4 GB of RAM, not 8.

But wait.The savings increase as you move up the model chart.

For example, a reasonably-configured Spectre x2, with a Core i5 processor, 8 GB of RAM, and 256 GB of SSD storage, will cost $1170. By comparison, a similarly configured Surface Pro (2017) would set you back over $1550. So that’s an incredible savings if you choose the HP.

The review unit includes a Core i7 processor, 16 GB of RAM, and a 360 GB SSD (an odd amount, I know). This model costs $1670, but it still represents a significant value over Surface, where a similarly configured model (with 512 GB of SSD storage) costs an incredible $2460 with the full accessory set. That’s almost $800 in savings for the HP.

There are a few other models, too, and you should be able to find one that matches your needs between HP.com and retailers like Best Buy. The most expensive Spectre x2 includes a Core i7 processor, 16 GB of RAM, and 1 TB of SSD storage for $1970.

Recommendations and conclusions

The HP Spectre x2 is the best overall 2-in-1 PC in the market today and is, by far, the best value. It falls short of the new Surface Pro in only two areas, fan noise and pen capabilities. But neither is likely to sway those customers who can save several hundred dollars by choosing the HP. And in doing so, they will get a more elegant and forward-leaning PC as well.

The HP Spectre x2 is an excellent combination of capability and value, and it is highly recommended.

At-a-glance

Pros

  • Stunning, elegant design
  • Modern components
  • Superior 2-in-1 keyboard cover
  • Reasonable pricing
  • Includes keyboard cover and active pen

Cons

  • Fan noise makes it louder than the new Surface Pro
  • Active pen falls short of new Surface Pen
  • McAfee security software, other crapware
  • Dongles required

 

Tagged with ,

Join the discussion!

BECOME A THURROTT MEMBER:

Don't have a login but want to join the conversation? Become a Thurrott Premium or Basic User to participate

Register
Comments (28)

28 responses to “HP Spectre x2 (2017) Review”

  1. bbold

    Great review! Me personally, I'm not a fan of the design, but that's just a personal pref.

  2. Imran Awan

    What is the price of this laptop to purchase in Pakistan?

    www.forumpakistan.com.pk/computers-f46.html

  3. sarahah site

    Thank you very much for this useful article. I like it.

    It’s really a great and helpful piece of line.I am glad that you shared 

    this helpful info with us. Please keep us informed like this.

    Thanks for sharing appvn app


  4. sarahah site

    I totally agree with you about creating a personalized email. I always write a new email whenever 

    I email someone asking them if I can guest post on their blog. You never want it to sound robotic.

     Also, be sure that you take the time to find the blog owners name and use it. sarahah site


  5. Angusmatheson

    It might be that running the fan is actually the best option. The core chips create a lot of heat. The only options are 1) limit the chip when it starts to get hot, 2) turn on a fan, or 3) just let it get hot which will limit the life of the components. Of those, turning on a fan (as annoying as it might be) get maximum performance when needed without hurting the components. I'd love to see the thermals on the chip and drive matched to performance for this HP specter x2, the surface pro, surface laptop, MacBook Pro - to see if the fan actually keeps things cooler or it is simply worse design that doesn't allow to to dissipate heat passively as well.

  6. IanYates82

    I'd consider windows 10 home, rather than pro, a con for most too.

    I have a hp envy 17 (including the faulty hinge) which has been great, but one annoying thing is that hp refused support when I wiped it and put on my company licence of Windows 8 enterprise (pre win 10 days). Clear driver issue with the display brightness not being changeable and Bluetooth frequently failing but they'd only support Windows with their original install. I hope that policy had changed as it made it hard to start with a fresh install, even though I used the hp support assistant to install the drivers (as you say, it's mostly excellent but does have a tendency to insist I have no internet connection and thus will no longer properly check for updates).

    End rant... ☺️


    I'll certainly consider this to replace my surface pro 3 when time comes.

  7. Orangeguy

    I just sold my Spectre x360 13" previous gen model and currently own a SP i5/8G/256G unit. The correction of including a working pen is a huge plus and HP was surprisingly good to work with on issues with the unit. All that being said I switched to the SP simply because I had trouble with units touch interface and getting the latest drivers. It was not a precision touchpad and it was flaky just enough to cause me to not trust it for smooth scrolling. Kudos to HP for choices, but having come out of the apple ecosystem I seem predisposed to trust the benefits of having the same HW and SW maker resolve issues and provide the best experience. - Nice review

  8. Chris Blair

    I'm a recent buyer of a Surface Pro i5/8G/256G and after a week or so of regular use (still) think it is a good choice relative to a similarly configured (but lower priced!) X2 model (cognitive dissonance anyone?). More specifically I'd point to the SP's better battery life, better (in my view) port selection, better pen experience, and cool / fanless design. But whether these advantages justify its higher price is, I believe, a buyer-specific decision. I'd also suggest that anyone considering the SP and X2 should check out their reviews / smackdowns on my other fav tech websites, Windows Central and MobileTechReview.


  9. Narg

    The wrist area and trackpad would be more usable if they'd opt to get rid of that stupid kick up feature of the keyboard. It just results in a bouncy typing experience. No thanks.

  10. George Perry

    Bought the I7 two weeks ago. I did appreciate the fact that the keyboard and pen came with the unit. And 360 gig storage vs 128 on the Surface Pro at the same or similar specs. I had purchased a new Surface Pro and it showed up with major flaws on the screen right out of the box so I sent it back and got the HP.


    My only regret is short battery life. I tuned the device to purge the garbage and turn off an major battery eaters which is what I do with all my new devices. Still, about 6 hours was the best I got day to day. I also realized that the HP can't be charged from a USB C / portable charger while powered up which was kind of a letdown as I had counted on this to charge while on the road as needed. After some further research it appears that you can charge the device with a portable charger and USB C cable but the unit has to be turned off. Kind of defeats the purpose. This is HP protecting themselves I guess. Since I usually have no less than 3 devices with me anyway, I ended up buying chargetech portable charger with AC built in and still came in under the Surface Pro price tag when including their pen and keyboard. This charger will charge the HP from 0 to 50 in 1/2 hour due to HP's fast charging. I was also was able to charge the entire device with the portable charger and still had power left on the charger.


    I personally just liked the typing experience and extra storage enough to keep the unit. Oh, and yes, the great screen.


  11. Andrew G

    Other reviewers note really bad thermals and a terrible battery life. I personally noted a bad pen experience - vectoring all over the place. Like Paul I love the design, the keyboard and the screen, but I can't rely on real-world ~5 hours of battery time (vs 8-9 hours on the Surface Pro) or a pen that sometimes can't find the screen. Deal with those and the HP Spectre would easily be the best device of its kind on the market, but it'll have to wait until the next generation I guess. Still, my respect to HP for making such big improvements.

  12. irfaanwahid

    I find it amusing when Paul says, x2 can be had for as little as $1150. The $1000 price has become so normal that it is no more considered expensive. I understand most of the premium devices are 1000 plus, but, IMHO $1000 is still a lot of money.

    • Daishi

      In reply to irfaanwahid:

      Yep, the prices on PCs are getting outrageous, but you should try doing it outside the US.


      For example, in Australia, where I live, the $1170 i5 8gb 256gb model Paul mentions costs the equivelant of US$1670, before our 10% sales tax. And that's the cheapest model they sell here. How they justify that 42% price hike is anyone's guess, but I have to assume it's because my country men and women are stupid enough to keep paying it.


      I know that "Premium" PCs are apparently one of the strongest parts of the PC market these days but it seriously just seems as if the OEMs have all just decided that that just means they should jack up their prices by 20% compare to 18 months ago and tell people it's Premium, while at the same time filling the $800-$1000 range with the same bulky, heavy, plastic garbage they used to sell for $500.

  13. Alexander Rothacker

    I bought an m3 Spectre x2 about a year and a half ago at some BestBuy sale for I think around $500. It had a crazy screen flicker bug that made me return it and instead buy an i5 SurfacePro 4. I love the SP4, but man that HP keyboard was just worlds better then the Surface keyboard. I really wish that MS would offer an additional keyboard option that might be a bit heavier and thicker, but had better key travel and wouldn't flex as much, I'd buy it in a heartbeat.


    If I were in the market to buy right now, I'd definitely get the HP offer the current SP.

  14. rameshthanikodi

    Does paul have a working relationship with HP or something?

  15. gmtom1

    Also, any thoughts on using the HP Pen vs. the new Bamboo Ink pen? Haven't seen too many reviews of the Bamboo ink yet, but I wasn't too impressed by the HP pen when I played with one on the Spectre 360 in the MS Store.



    • Andrew G

      In reply to gmtom1:

      I tried the Bamboo Ink on the HP Spectre X2 and it was lovely - a nice experiential improvement over the HP pen that comes in the box. However, I found there was plenty vectoring with either pen. I don't think HP has mastered palm rejection yet. I can't wait to see the next iteration of the x2 though.

  16. gmtom1

    Hope you'll be reviewing its sister device, the Elite X2 1012 "G2" I'm looking at that device instead, since it has TB3, optional fingerprint support, and WWAN available in essentially the same package as this, minus the pretty appearance.

  17. Bdsrev

    I want this but the crapware is a deal breaker. Why wouldn't they sell a Windows 10 S version? Many would gladly pay extra to have a clean version of Windows 10 out of the box. This is the reason so many are buying Surfaces, Microsoft deserves the business. Also, 3000 x 2000 on a screen of this size is overkill and a waste of battery life. The SP4 display is already arguably a bit too pixel dense

  18. skane2600

    I haven't paid over $1000 for a computer since the Windows 2000 days, but if I were willing to, I can't see buying an expensive PC that doesn't come with Windows Pro.

  19. MacLiam

    Informative review. If I had not bought a new mid-range SP (i7, but middling RAM and storage) for knockabout computing about six weeks ago, I'd be looking at this one right now. But I don't regret being an early adopter of the new SP, which is a fine machine and, in my judgment, worth what I paid for it.

  20. TravisGreuel

    Windows 10 Home should be listed as a con. I'd rather see it come with 10s to qualify this year for the free upgrade to Pro.

    • Polycrastinator

      In reply to TravisGreuel:

      Windows 10 Home is the version most consumers are going to want. The upgrade to Pro isn't something that most consumers need. I understand that in the case of IT Pros that's not right, but we do need to remember we're edge cases, not the mainstream.

      • wright_is

        In reply to Polycrastinator:

        I still thing they should get rid of Windows 10 (Standard/Home) and just make Pro the entry level. We are constantly buying high performance notebooks, which usually means gaming notebooks, then having to upgrade them to Pro as the first part of setting them up.

        At home, I have always used Pro, my Spectre x360 is only on Windows 10 and I miss some features.

        • IanYates82

          In reply to wright_is:

          Agreed. I'd like to suggest this to clients to use with our software rather than the surface, but only coming with home just makes it harder since it's not an all-up purchase in one go. For fair apples to apples the cost of the windows licence should be factored in to the review.

Leave a Reply