The Problem with Windows 10 on ARM (Premium)

While many will point to its performance and app compatibility issues, the biggest problem with Windows 10 on ARM is hubris. This platform exists for only one reason, which is to screw over Intel. And that is not an origin story to be proud of. Nor is it a solid strategy for success.

I'm reminded of Microsoft's initial efforts around the Zune, it's ill-conceived and ill-fated digital music player. At the time, the software giant was suffering from early-onset Apple envy and it still believed that the Microsoft brand meant a damn to consumers.

The result was Zune, a me-too product that was rushed to market in 2006 with no meaningful differentiators over the iPod it sought to supplant. Microsoft's marketing highlighted its own cluelessness. "Hello from Seattle" replaced "Designed by Apple in California." And "Welcome to the social" simply emphasized the fact that no one else was even using the thing; the "social" bit is exactly what was missing.

But the overwhelming issue with Zune wasn't its terrible re-skinned Windows Media Player software, its incompatible, proprietary media formats, or the pointlessness of "squirting" songs to others. It was hubris: Microsoft still believed in 2006 that it could grab market share simply by showing up. It never even attempted to understand why Apple's devices were so popular or what it would take---a miracle---to drive an exodus from a music platform that, frankly, its users really enjoyed.

What the iPod should have been is a wake-up call about Microsoft's standing in the world: After all, most iPod users were Windows users, too. And instead of focusing on that inconvenient truth, some Xbox guys---who were much less insightful and successful than they thought they were---dumped Zune into the market. The rest, as they say, was history.

Flash forward to today and Microsoft is making the same kind of mistake with Windows 10 on ARM. This should worry anyone who cares about Windows or this company. This system literally only exists because Microsoft wants to shake up Intel's market dominance. If all this platform achieves is to make Intel wake up and improve the mobile characteristics of its own processors, Microsoft will consider this a win.

But why would anyone normal care about this kind of thing? What we should be concerned about is how well Windows 10 on ARM works.

It's not good news: Windows 10 on ARM makes absolutely no sense at all. Not today, on a traditional PC, which is what each of the first PCs based on this system is. A PC.

Consider the following observation that I made in Windows 10 Lean (Premium) earlier today, about Windows 10 S.

"Windows 10 S was always aiming at a future in which Microsoft could finally shed the Win32 legacy past of Windows and emerge with a more modern platform that would better fit within the functional and security needs of mobile devices and software delivered as a service," I wrote. "We could logically view the initial release of this system--...

Gain unlimited access to Premium articles.

With technology shaping our everyday lives, how could we not dig deeper?

Thurrott Premium delivers an honest and thorough perspective about the technologies we use and rely on everyday. Discover deeper content as a Premium member.

Tagged with

Share post

Please check our Community Guidelines before commenting

Windows Intelligence In Your Inbox

Sign up for our new free newsletter to get three time-saving tips each Friday

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Thurrott © 2024 Thurrott LLC