Windows 11: A Few More Screenshots

Posted on June 15, 2021 by Paul Thurrott in Windows 11 with 60 Comments

The more I dive into Windows 11, the more it’s obvious that this is literally just Windows 10 with a fresh coat of paint. At least for now.

And that’s fine: As you may recall, I wrote in Windows 11? (Premium) that such a change would be enough to justify the version increase and present a fresh face to the world. And I feel like we have more changes coming, as some key UIs that should be changing—Settings, Microsoft Store, and all the built-in apps like Mail and Calendar—are exactly as they are today in Windows 10.

But anyone who was hoping that Microsoft’s UX upgrade would somehow extend to legacy UIs like Control Panel and the Microsoft Management Console (MMC), will need to adjust their expectations. I don’t see that ever happening, and there’s certainly no evidence of it here.

With all that in mind, here are some more screenshots of this new system.

Join the discussion!

BECOME A THURROTT MEMBER:

Don't have a login but want to join the conversation? Become a Thurrott Premium or Basic User to participate

Register
Comments (60)

60 responses to “Windows 11: A Few More Screenshots”

  1. shark47

    "But anyone who was hoping that Microsoft’s UX upgrade would somehow extend to legacy UIs like Control Panel and the Microsoft Management Console (MMC), will need to adjust their expectations. I don’t see that ever happening, and there’s certainly no evidence of it here."


    That's annoying. They've been on this path for over a decade now and still haven't achieved it.

    • lvthunder

      I don't think they have been on this path for a decade. I think they decided to never update those parts again and when they finish building its replacement and it's complete they will depreciate the old stuff and remove it from Windows.

    • tekisasujohn

      I don't understand why they wouldn't update the titlebar and at least try to mimic new widget styles with an updated msstyles theme.


      I remember when the "designers" that put Gnome 3 together pushed out their desktop shell, even they had the good sense to release a gtk2 theme along with the gtk3 one so at least those applications would look *somewhat* similar side by side with the new stuff.


      It seemed like they were finally fixing the titlebar portion of this with Sets way back when but they threw the baby out with the bathwater when it was cancelled.


      My theory is that they purposefully allowed legacy desktop applications to bitrot (despite still being heavily and dominantly used today) with regard to UI in order to incentivize/con/trick developers into downgrading their full featured applications into feature-anemic apps because only the apps used the newer theming. That failed spectacularly for a decade straight, like everything Microsoft did 2012-2022 with Windows, so if this was the case I'm confused why they think it would work now.

      • tekisasujohn

        After looking at some more screenshots and videos of people using the leaked build, it does look like they've given some attention to the widget styles to try to better match WinUI2/3, so that's much appreciated. If they could enforce Compact Mode from WinUI3 as the default for desktop with keyboard and mouse mode, I would be supremely happy. For the titlebar, I wouldn't mind either plain white/black/acrylic/whatever, but I'd want it to stay consistent. No more surprise vertical menubars. I hope that's going to be permanently labelled A Bad Idea(tm) going forward. The traditional File/Edit/View style menu bars house *multiple* vertical menubars in less space and they don't require you to compromise your feature-rich application in an effort to emulate a mobile platform that doesn't exist anymore.


        And this is a leaked build, so I'll definitely be staying tuned for further developments. The Settings app looks very much out of place in the old square design so I can't wait to see how they've tackled that. I don't want a return to Control Panel per se, but I do want a Settings app that doesn't look like a mobile app (again, to mimic a mobile platform that doesn't even exist anymore) and doesn't take 6+ clicks to do what used to take 3+/- in Control Panel.


        Gotta say they've done a great job at making Windows look beautiful again. Haven't seen this in a decade. The people making the backgrounds, widget styles, animations, and icons all need raises.

    • oadrian

      I think the issue with Control Panel and MMC is that they're built on the concept of pluggable panels where a lot of the content for those panels are owned by 3rd parties. And if the companies that produced those plugins weren't interested in updating their control panels or MMC plugins because they can't be bothered or because they no longer exist, then people who rely on unfortunately ancient (in computer years) software would be out of luck.


      That's also what prevents Microsoft from updating the look of control panels and MMC plugins that they don't own. I've produced a couple in my years and you're responsible for creating the UI yourself and frequently you have to opt in to a particular version of the common controls. So there might be a forwarding of common control versions, but that's probably rare or hard to pull off.


      Ultimately, the control panels and MMC plugins are a legacy technology that really doesn't have a lot of options for being brought into modern design. That's primarily why for 1st party stuff, they're not making new items.


      But they have to be there for 3rd party components, drivers, etc. Otherwise your very expensive many tens of thousands of dollars piece of chemistry equipment won't work anymore on the newest version of Windows. The fact that a lot of decades old software still works on Windows is a testament to not leaving large-scale entities behind.

  2. navarac

    If my "muscle memory" is tested, I'm off to Linux permanently.

    • behindmyscreen

      regardless of that, I am planning a move over to Linux anyway. I am waiting for my new 1 TB SSD for my laptop and then I will partition and duel boot. If I can get all my work done on Linux then I will make the move permanent.


      I don't hate windows. I just want something that is going to be more....mine.

  3. scovious

    If you right click the title bar (where the minimize, maximize and close buttons are) while in Dark Mode, is the drop box still white?

  4. jhambi

    Where is phone dialer?? Please tell me it is still there...

    • locust_infested_orchard_inc.

      It appears you're anticipating Panos Panay to pronounce a Windows-powered Surface Foldable™ a reality at some point in time.


      I believe that depends on Pat Gelsinger to kick Intel into shape and concoct a Y-monikered SoC that excels in both performance and battery-charge longevity, whilst being affordable.


      Whether the soon-to-be-released 12th generation Alder Lake will be up to the task remains to be seen.

  5. hrlngrv

    With respect to Windows Management Console, how often does anyone here use it? I suppose those who use lots of new non-phone cameras might have to use Device Manager more often than normal users, but many others? OTOH, I figure there's a small cadre of admins who use it a few times a week if not more often. Would they benefit from a UI overhaul? Or, perhaps, would a UI overhaul which benefited frequent WMC users benefit infrequent WMC users?


    Using an analog, is Notepad screaming for a ribbon UI?

  6. AlexKven

    "The more I dive into Windows 11, the more it’s obvious that this is literally just Windows 10 with a fresh coat of paint. At least for now."


    What I feel like might be coming is Microsoft pulling a fast one and calling it something other than Windows 11. I've felt that more with every 11 clue they dropped. Early leaked Windows 8 milestones were quite misleading about what Windows 8 was, and everyone was about to write the stories about Windows 9 when Microsoft announced Windows 10.

  7. Elan Gabriel

    Thanks for the screenshots. Could you please take one with an open left alignment Start Menu.

  8. stijnhommes

    The first thing I notice is how the taskbar is treated like we're on a tablet. Desktop users are getting screwed again and people who don't want or need a new look probably won't be able to turn this crap off.

    • javial

      Since Windows 8, Windows is designed to be a mobile/smartphone OS with mobile/smartphone apps (UWP) that also runs on desktop. Mobile first, cloud first and desktop never again.

      • Paul Thurrott

        Windows 10 reversed that.
        • javial

          Settings in Windows 10 has a mobile smartphone UI, there are a lot of telephony and call settings in Windows 10 like a mobile, UWP are smartphones apps, screen based, bigest fonts, limited, less featured, slowly, take times to open, only one window/instance per app, etc. No sense for a desktop OS.

    • behindmyscreen

      Chrome OS, Mac OS, XFCE on Linux all use a central doc with app launcher somewhere in that central dock. It's not some "tablet" thing.

  9. ianw789

    On the trip to the Apple paint store needed for this Windows OSX project, did they deprecate anything? Or fix any broken things? Or enhance the security? Re-architect to reduce CPU platform dependency? ...


    I will be watching with interest as the details emerge.

  10. Greg Green

    This is supposed to get consumers and business excited for new expenditures and training classes? I don’t think so. They’ve really run out of good ideas.

    • crashnburnxp

      It's funny too because most business arent even on the latest 21H2 build let alone 1909 and here MS is trying to release Windows 11. Either MS needs to slow down or business need to start playing catchup more quickly

  11. crunchyfrog

    So Apple moves to Mac OS 11, has centered taskbar icons and fancy animations. Am I seeing a pattern here?

  12. ebraiter

    If not mentioned, having the icons in the center bottom reminds me of macOS. Will Apple sue? :-)

  13. datameister

    What about tabbed apps (i.e. Groupy). Is that ever going to be a thing?

  14. jdawgnoonan

    It doesn't look like a huge change, but overall I feel okay about it. I was bugged by the centered application icons and the left justified systray until I saw the screenshot that shows you can align the applications to the left. Having centered icons with the systray over there would really bother me more than it likely should.

    • Maverick010

      I think it was done that way purposely to show that even the start icon is no longer stationary on the left and the maybe even hints that Windows 11 will be significantly more customizable with the GUI this go around. That is my best guess, as part of me liked it but another part said, I will keep going to the bottom left corner lol.

  15. dougkinzinger

    Dang. I bet MSFT is ticked with the leak.

  16. dxtremebob

    I'm hoping they keep Start Menu Folders. I use them a lot.


    Regarding Live Tiles, they were a good idea, but are largely unsupported.

    • hrlngrv

      Live tiles may have been worthwhile on phones, since phone users glance at their phones periodically. Any benefit on PCs was dubious since one had to have their Start menu open to see them, and PC users don't tend to open their Start menus periodically just to glance at them.

      • rycott

        Live tiles would have been way more useful if you could have pinned them to your desktop.

        • SvenJ

          We called those Windows 7 Gadgets. They weren't well supported either.

        • hrlngrv

          So a Rainmeter replacement?


          Curios: how many 3rd party apps provide live tiles? Or are damn near all live tiles produced by MSFT's own apps? Since Windows 8 I've had News, Finance, Weather, Alarms, Calendar and Mail in live tiles, and for a while in Windows 8.x something named MClock which provided an analog clock on the Windows 8.x start screen which didn't display a clock. Those are the only live tiles I've ever used, and none of the dozen-odd 3rd party apps I've installed since Windows 8.0 have provided useful live tiles.

          • rycott

            The problem is live tiles on Windows 10 were in a pretty useless spot. Stick them somewhere a bit more useful and maybe people might have supported them more. Or maybe they wouldn't have... but it would have had at least a fighting chance.

            • hrlngrv

              | at least a fighting chance


              There's a registry hack to revert to the Windows 10-style Start menu complete with live tiles. If MSFT doesn't add it as a setting under Settings > Personalization > Start, I figure it may have gone the way of adjusting desktop icon spacing, a feature Windows still supports but that MSFT doesn't want anyone to use, so makes it difficult to use.

    • Cardch

      I don’t care about the Live bit but I definitely want Start Tiles to remain. They are a great way of highlighting most commonly used apps without having a desktop that looks like you’ve thrown up a bunch of icons all over.

  17. bart

    Not hard to imagine how Microsoft sells this to the enterprise as a minor update. Especially if the Start menu is back on the left hand bottom.

    But am very interested to hear from Microsoft how they are going to sell this to consumers/prosumers as 'the next generation of Windows'.

  18. JacobTheDev

    I always get excited for visual refreshes, these changes look pretty nice. I don't expect things like Control Panel and MMC to get updated, but if we could get updates for things like File Explorer and Notepad, that'd be awesome. There's an argument to be made for "if it ain't broke, don't fix it," but it sort of drives me crazy how dated File Explorer looks compared to their other apps. It'd be nice to get some acrylic effects and stuff like that. Icon updates are a good start, though!

  19. bluvg

    "it’s obvious that this is literally just Windows 10 with a fresh coat of paint. At least for now."


    According to some CPU industry trackers, there are major changes coming to the scheduler to accommodate the new Intel hybrid CPUs.

  20. srrlx1986

    So how many spinal tap references do you expect in the announcement?

  21. codymesh

    Hopefully Microsoft at least shows what their vision is for a thorough visual overhaul of the system instead of pretending like all the Win32 stuff doesn't exist.

  22. ngc224

    Yes, I will be that troll that once again points out this was not a “leak,” but a controlled release preview for a news cycle before next week.


    Why I care? Because I want to be able to trust Microsoft (and Paul) even with the small stuff.


    • Paul Thurrott

      Well, thanks for preemptively not trusting me.


      This was not leaked by Microsoft to me or us. It is a leak. I don't know where it came from.

      • samp

        On all the sites I follow, they all say 'they don't know where it came from'. What does that mean? it must be downloaded from somewhere.

      • hrlngrv

        If you don't know where it came from, it could be from MSFT.


        From a different perspective, if this wasn't leaked by a current or very recently terminated MSFT employee, what would that say for MSFT security?

    • tekisasujohn

      Paul is perhaps the only journalist covering Windows that I trust implicitly. Look back at the history of this site and WinSuperSite before it. He's even been regularly criticized by yes-men journalists and fanboys for (rightfully) criticizing Microsoft when they've made clearly bad decisions (see the UWP saga for acute examples). It's not his m.o. to bs people into some cringeworthy PR scheme to astroturf some new Microsoft product or service as implied.


      It's the people covering Windows professionally that have a history of championing Windows 8, 10, and 11 as though each in their time have had zero flaws that I would consider suspect.

  23. allanwith

    Honestly, they could have called it Windows 10.5 and tempered expectations more, but it is what it is. I like this choice, as opposed to going with 10x. I mean, I'm totally sympathetic to the idea of 10x, shedding much of the old legacy, but at the same time, the legacy stuff is what gives Windows its core value.


    I'm curious as to whether they will at least start removing stuff like ActiveX and old background services to at least slim Windows down a bit.

Leave a Reply